Priviet Social Sciences Journal

The capital buffer paradox: Strong heterogeneity in profitability determinants between small and over capitalized banks in Indonesia

by Baharuddin Baharuddin , Budi Krisnanto , Abdul Gafar Samalam , Muhammad Rizal
Vol. 5 No. 12 (2025): December 2025

Abstract

The Indonesian banking sector faces a paradox of maintaining high capital buffers for stability while pursuing profitability amid digital disruption. This study examines the profitability determinants of conventional commercial banks, with a novel focus on testing the moderating role of the Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR) in the loan-to-deposit ratio (LDR) and return on assets (ROA) relationship a mechanism hypothesized to explain previous empirical inconsistencies. Using quarterly panel data from 43 banks from Q1 2020 to Q3 2025 (989 observations) and a Fixed Effects model corrected with robust standard errors, the results reveal three key findings. First, the moderation hypothesis is rejected; high capital buffers do not significantly alter the impact of LDR on ROA. Second, operational efficiency (BOPO) proves to be the most consistent and dominant determinant of profitability. Most importantly, the key contribution lies in the discovery of sharp heterogeneity: traditional determinant models exhibit very strong explanatory power (R² = 66%) for small banks (CAR ≤ 25.1%) but fail to explain profitability for large, over capitalized banks (R² = 26.1%), where no traditional variables are significant. This demonstrates that profitability drivers evolve with bank scale, rendering one size fits all policy and strategic approaches ineffective. Consequently, regulators must implement differentiated macroprudential policies, while bank management should tailor core strategies based on their specific segment.

References

  1. Acosta-Smith, J., Grill, M., & Lang, J. H. (2020). The leverage ratio, risk-taking and bank stability. Journal of Financial Stability. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.JFS.2020.100833
  2. Alazis, M. (2020). Effect of car, ldr, roa, roa and nim toward the commercial bank in indonesia. https://doi.org/10.29040/IJEBAR.V4I01.954
  3. Andriani, D., Maritasari, D. B., Laela, I., & Husnadia, S. (2025). Pemilihan Teknik Sampling yang Tepat Dalam Penelitian Kualitatif: Literature Review. Indo-MathEdu Intellectuals Journal. https://doi.org/10.54373/imeij.v6i4.3783
  4. Anggawulan, M. D. D., & Suardikha, I. M. S. (2021). Capital Adequacy Ratio, Loan to Deposit Ratio, Ukuran Perusahaan dan Return On Assets dengan Non Performing Loan sebagai Variabel Pemoderasi. E-Jurnal Akuntansi. https://doi.org/10.24843/EJA.2021.V31.I01.P10
  5. ANTARA. (2025). OJK proyeksi kinerja bank tetap stabil di tengah dinamika ekonomi. https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5002773/ojk-proyeksi-kinerja-bank-tetap-stabil-di-tengah-dinamika-ekonomi
  6. Barakat, S. (2023). Review of Classical Methods and Variables Selection in Case of Multicollinearity: A Case Study with Real-Data. https://doi.org/10.21608/caf.2023.336191
  7. Barker, D. K. S. (2022). Does loan growth impact on bank risk? Heliyon. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2022.e10319
  8. Berggren, M. (2024). Coefficients of determination measured on the same scale as the outcome: Alternatives to R2 that use standard deviations instead of explained variance. Psychological Methods. https://doi.org/10.1037/met0000681
  9. Cahyani, L. S., Tripuspitorini, F. A., & Nurdin, A. (2022). Pengaruh CAR, LDR dan NIM terhadap ROA Pada Bank Umum yang Terdaftar di BEI. Indonesian Journal of Economics and Management. https://doi.org/10.35313/ijem.v2i2.3139
  10. Cathleen, A., & Ekadjaja, A. (2023). The effect of financial ratios on financial performance among banking companies. International Journal of Application on Economics and Business. https://doi.org/10.24912/ijaeb.v1i3.1074-1086
  11. Dari, N. K. P., & Suarjaya, A. A. G. (2025). The Effect of NPL, LDR, CAR, NIM, and BOPO on Profitability. International Journal of Asian Business and Management. https://doi.org/10.55927/ijabm.v4i4.470
  12. de Haan, J., Rodriguez Moreno, M., & Segev, N. (2023). The impact of low interest rates on banks’ net interest margins: An overview. https://doi.org/10.1016/b978-0-44-313776-1.00184-7
  13. Erdoğan, B. (2024). Analysis of factors influencing banks’ profitability using panel data models. Journal of Life Economics. https://doi.org/10.15637/jlecon.2560
  14. Fadhila, N. N., & Ardila, I. (2023). Pengaruh Non Performing Financing dan Return On Assets Terhadap Perubahan Laba. Jurnal Akuntansi Dan Manajemen. https://doi.org/10.59086/jam.v2i2.333
  15. Fahlenbrach, R., Prilmeier, R., & Stulz, R. M. (2018). Why Does Fast Loan Growth Predict Poor Performance for Banks. Review of Financial Studies. https://doi.org/10.1093/RFS/HHX109
  16. Gaytán Cortés, J. (2025). ROIC (Return on Invested Capital), as a metric of financial efficiency. Mercados y Negocios. https://doi.org/10.32870/myn.vi56.7971
  17. Hailu, G. K., Demissie, W. M., & Fekede, E. A. (2024). Exploring the Holistic Determinants of Bank Performance in East African Countries. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4854429
  18. Haris, M., Tan, Y., Malik, A., & Ain, Q. U. (2020). A study on the impact of capitalization on the profitability of banks in emerging markets: A case of Pakistan. https://doi.org/10.3390/JRFM13090217
  19. Hasbi, H., Djaniar, U., Putri, P., Irdawati, I. I., & Anantadjaya, S. P. D. (2024). Efektivitas Net Interest Margin dan Loan to Deposit Ratio Terhadap Profitabilitas Perbankan. Briliant : Jurnal Riset Dan Konseptual. https://doi.org/10.28926/briliant.v9i1.1627
  20. Hidayat, D., Sakifah, S., & Masitoh, N. (2025). Navigating Financial Performance: The Influence of NPL and LDR on ROA with Inflation as a Moderating Factor. EKOMA : Jurnal Ekonomi, Manajemen, Akuntansi. https://doi.org/10.56799/ekoma.v4i2.7008
  21. Hudaja, E. A. S., & Marlina, M. A. E. (2024). Pengaruh npl dan nim terhadap nilai perusahaan perbankan menurut kelompok bank berdasarkan modal inti. Ekombis Sains: Jurnal Ekonomi, Keuangan Dan Bisnis. https://doi.org/10.24967/ekombis.v9i2.3106
  22. Iacobucci, D., Schneider, M. J., Popovich, D., & Bakamitsos, G. A. (2017). Mean centering, multicollinearity, and moderators in multiple regression: The reconciliation redux. Behavior Research Methods. https://doi.org/10.3758/S13428-016-0827-9
  23. Jultantyo, S., Hasan, K., & Anggarani, D. (2025). Analisis Efisiensi Perbankan Berdasarkan Rasio Keuangan pada PT. Bank Rakyat Indonesia. Deleted Journal. https://doi.org/10.62335/aksioma.v2i8.1602
  24. Karadayi, N. (2023). The effect of Loan to Deposit Ratio (LDR), Non-Performing Loan (NPL), Other Operating Expenses, and Non-Interest Income on Profitability (ROA). International Journal of Scientific and Research Publications. https://doi.org/10.29322/ijsrp.13.01.2023.p13348
  25. Le, T. D., Ngo, T., & Ngo, T. (2020). The determinants of bank profitability: A cross-country analysis. Central Bank Review. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.CBREV.2020.04.001
  26. Lembaga Pengembangan Perbankan Indonesia, L. P. P. I. (2024). Outlook Perbankan Indonesia 2024. https://lppi.or.id/
  27. Liu, J., & Sun, H. (2022). Impact of BOPS and ES on Demand and Profitability: Theoretical Models and Simulation Analysis. Proceedings of the International Conference on Big Data Economy and Digital Management. https://doi.org/10.5220/0011359800003440
  28. Maghfuriyah, A., Permatasari, A. I., Nurjaya, & Setiawan, T. (2023). Influence Of The Loan-To-Deposit Ratio On The Return On Assets In Banking Companies Listed On The Indonesian Stock Exchange During The Period 2015-2019. Neo Journal of Economy and Social Humanities. https://doi.org/10.56403/nejesh.v2i4.141
  29. Marlina, R. (2023). Determinants of capital adequacy ratio bank in Indonesia. https://doi.org/10.32770/jbfem.vol687-96
  30. Meidi, L., & Tannia, T. (2025). Factors Influencing Bank Profitability: A Study of Indonesian Commercial Banks. Petra International Journal of Business Studies. https://doi.org/10.9744/petraijbs.8.1.88-97
  31. Mobonggi, I. D., Achmad, N., Resmawan, R., & Hasan, I. K. (2022). Analisis regresi data panel dengan pendekatan common effect model dan fixed effect model pada kasus produksi tanaman jagung. Interval : Jurnal Ilmiah Matematika. https://doi.org/10.33751/interval.v2i2.6516
  32. Muhammad, M., Sesa Lestari An, P., Humaira S. S., S., Handini, A. A., & Sumantri, F. (2025). Analisis Pengaruh CAR, NPL, dan LDR Pada ROA Bank Cimb Niaga Tahun 2003–2023. Mizania. https://doi.org/10.47776/mizania.v2i2.1654
  33. Mulbah, K. T., Kurbonov, S., & Nasriddinov, B. (2024). The Effect of Bank Size, Net Interest Margin, and Capital Adequacy Ratio on Commercial Banks’ Return on Assets: Empirical Evidence from Tanzania. European Scientific Journal, ESJ. https://doi.org/10.19044/esipreprint.4.2024.p474
  34. Nadia, L. P., Putri, A. R. Y., & Sa’adah, W. N. (2025). Navigating risk and growth: how loan quality and credit growth shape bank profitability in ASEAN commercial banks. https://doi.org/10.31603/biseb.231
  35. Obeid, R. (2025). Factors affecting net interest margin in the banking sector: Evidence from the Arab region. Journal of Governance and Regulation. https://doi.org/10.22495/jgrv13i1art19
  36. Olaniran, S. F., Olaniran, O. R., Allohibi, J., & Alharbi, A. A. (2024). A Novel Approach for Testing Fractional Cointegration in Panel Data Models with Fixed Effects. Fractal and Fractional. https://doi.org/10.3390/fractalfract8090527
  37. Olvera Astivia, O. L., & Kroc, E. (2019). Centering in Multiple Regression Does Not Always Reduce Multicollinearity: How to Tell When Your Estimates Will Not Benefit From Centering. Educational and Psychological Measurement. https://doi.org/10.1177/0013164418817801
  38. Omelyanchuk, I. V. (2023). Data Analysis and Econometric Models. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-30058-5_5
  39. Otoritas Jasa Keuangan, O. J. K. (2024). Statistik Perbankan Indonesia Triwulan IV 2023 dan Kuartal I 2024. https://ojk.go.id/id/data-dan-statistik/laporan-tahunan/default.aspx
  40. Otoritas Jasa Keuangan, O. J. K. (2025a). Booklet Perbankan Indonesia 2025. https://www.ojk.go.id/id/kanal/perbankan/data-dan-statistik/booklet-perbankan-indonesia/Pages/Booklet-Perbankan-Indonesia-2025.aspx
  41. Otoritas Jasa Keuangan, O. J. K. (2025b). Laporan Surveillance Perbankan Indonesia (LSPI) Triwulan II 2025. Otoritas Jasa Keuangan (OJK). https://www.ojk.go.id/id/kanal/perbankan/data-dan-statistik/laporan-profil-industri-perbankan/Default.aspx
  42. Piracha, S., Hiba, H., Farooq, U., Fatima, U., Aslam, F., Ishaq, A., & Sial, H. (2022). New Insights and Different Economic Factors in Banking Sectors and Current Challenges. Scholars Bulletin. https://doi.org/10.36348/sb.2022.v08i02.005
  43. Pötscher, B. M., & Preinerstorfer, D. (2018). Controlling the Size of Autocorrelation Robust Tests. Journal of Econometrics. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.JECONOM.2018.08.005
  44. Puspitasari, E., Sudiyatno, B., Aini, N., & Anindiansyah, G. (2021). The Relationship Between Net Interest Margin and Return on Asset: Empirical Study of Conventional Banking in Indonesia. Academic Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies. https://doi.org/10.36941/AJIS-2021-0090
  45. Putri, A. R., & Lestari, T. (2025). Analisis Pengaruh Capital Adequacy Ratio, Biaya Operasional dan Pendapatan Operasional Terhadap Return On Asset Perbankan Periode 2021-2024. Jurnal Manajemen, Ekonomi Dan Akuntansi. https://doi.org/10.63921/jmaeka.v1i4.182
  46. Putri, S. O. D., & Pristiana, U. (2025). Pengaruh Financial Technology, Fee-Based Income, dan Biaya Operasional Pendapatan Operasional terhadap Profitabilitas Perusahaan Perbankan Syariah yang Terdaftar di Bursa Efek Indonesia. Jurnal Manajemen Bisnis Era Digital. https://doi.org/10.61132/jumabedi.v2i3.718
  47. Salsabila, R., & Hasrina, Y. (2023). Pengaruh Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR) Terhadap Return On Assets (ROA) (Studi Pada Laporan Tahunan PT Bank Rakyat Indonesia (Persero) Tbk Tahun 2019-2022). Journal of Management, Entrepreneur and Cooperative. https://doi.org/10.56869/jmec.v2i2.508
  48. Sardjono, W., Pranata, D. S., & Ramdhana, A. A. D. (2024). The Banking Industry is Undergoing a Digital Transformation as Part of Industrial 4.0. https://doi.org/10.1109/icscc62041.2024.10690753
  49. Sazahra, K., & Efriyanto, E. (2025). Analisis Pengaruh NPL dan LDR terhadap ROA Bank BJB 2019–2024. Journal of Artificial Intelligence and Digital Business. https://doi.org/10.31004/riggs.v4i2.1781
  50. Sembiring, R. P. B., & Wulandari, I. A. (2023). Pengaruh roa, roe, dan npl terhadap likuiditas perbankan. Jurnal Ekonomi Pembangunan STIE Muhammadiyah Palopo. https://doi.org/10.35906/jep.v9i2.1790
  51. Sousa, F., & Almeida, L. (2025). Banking Profitability: Evolution and Research Trends. International Journal of Financial Studies. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijfs13030139
  52. Sudimoro, S. T. Q. (2023). Pengaruh dana pihak ketiga (dpk), capital adequacy ratio (car), non performing loan (npl), net interest margin (nim), dan loan to deposit ratio (ldr) terhadap penyaluran kredit. https://doi.org/10.21776/csefb.2023.02.1.12
  53. Warsiati, W., Sukarno, H. B., & Hernawati, E. (2025). Pengaruh non performing loan (npl) dan belanja operasional pendapatan operasional (bopo) terhadap roa. Jurnal Ekbis (Ekonomi & Bisnis). https://doi.org/10.56689/ekbis.v13i1.1930